Located in the prestigious waterfront enclave of North Haven Point on 3.5 lush acres, this sought-after two-home compound boasts a private beach overlooking Shelter Island's ferry crossing. Set in a community abounding with manicured homes, winding tree lined roads and community tennis, this property hosts two dream homes creating a compound retreat on the water. One home for you and the other for your guests. Your 5-bedroom, 5 bath, 5,000+ sq. ft. home overlooks the gunite pool and spa to verdant gardens that lead to water separating North Haven and Shelter Island. Ample space for entertaining by the fireplace in the library or living room. Dining room and eat-in gourmet kitchen to fulfill your epicurean delights. Separate staff quarters.The guest house showcases waterviews and sunsets looking towards Shelter Island. Guests can enjoy this 3,000 sq. ft., 5 five-bedroom, 4.5 bath home with den, two fireplaces, bright, architectural barn style home with gunite pool and spa. Second master suite on the second floor with translucent water views and an open deck off the master bath. If you seek a balance between tranquility, privacy and lavish entertaining, this compound retreat is for you. Moments away from Sag Harbor Village and Shelter Island.