Experience the ultimate Montauk retreat with this charming, updated 1939 compound set on a secluded .89-acre flag lot. The 2500sf main house offers three spacious bedrooms, two baths, and hardwood floors throughout. Historic charm meets modern comfort with three fireplaces, multiple living spaces, and a first-floor primary featuring an en-suite bath and separate steam sauna in the partially finished basement. The property also benefits from key updates including: -Foundation fully sealed in 2006 and two sump pumps added -Boiler updated in 2004 -Guest cottage completely renovated in 2006 -Main house roof, septic, meters, breakers, and two new above ground oil tanks updated in 2008 -Second floor AC updated in 2014, with the rest of the house updated in 2022 -Addition of a steam sauna and water filtration system The property includes an ultra rare one-bedroom, two-bath 600sf guest cottage-ideal for guests or a unique income producing opportunity-plus room for a pool. A detached garage, currently outfitted as a woodworking studio, and an additional tool shed complete the experience. The lush, mature landscaping surrounds the home with a sense of serenity, creating a true private compound feel. Don't miss this rare Montauk gem with endless possibilities!